Arsenal’s summer transfer strategy is already a hot topic, with many fans and analysts convinced that signing a world-class striker is the missing piece in their Premier League title puzzle. But former Liverpool star Jamie Carragher has delivered a brutal reality check to Mikel Arteta and Arsenal’s decision-makers: A new No.9 isn’t the priority—they need more creativity instead.
Arsenal’s Title Hopes Fading—Again
For the third straight season, Arsenal look set to fall short in the Premier League title race. Despite being one of the most consistent teams under Arteta, they currently trail league leaders Liverpool by a massive 15 points. The lack of goals in crucial matches has led many to believe that failing to sign an elite striker last summer was a costly mistake.
With the 2025-26 season in sight, Arsenal’s transfer plans are already being mapped out, and all signs point to them splashing big money on a striker. Names like Benjamin Sesko (RB Leipzig) and Alexander Isak (Newcastle United) are reportedly high on their wishlist. However, Carragher believes that Arsenal’s real issue isn’t their finishing—it’s their lack of creativity.
Carragher’s Bold Verdict: Forget the Striker, Fix the Midfield
Speaking on Sky Sports, Carragher made his stance crystal clear: Arsenal’s attack isn’t struggling because of Kai Havertz or a lack of a clinical striker—it’s because they’re not creating enough chances.
“Is Kai Havertz world-class? Possibly not. But I think he does a great job for that team. His all-round play, not just scoring goals, is valuable,” Carragher explained. “Could they improve in that area? Maybe. But it’s not easy.”
Carragher pointed out that many of the Premier League’s biggest clubs have also struggled to find top-tier strikers in recent years. According to him:
– Liverpool signed Darwin Nunez—but he hasn’t been clinical enough.
– Manchester United signed Rasmus Højlund—but he’s still raw and inconsistent.
– Chelsea signed Nicolas Jackson—but he hasn’t proven himself as an elite No.9.
If even these wealthy, high-profile clubs have failed to find a guaranteed goalscorer, what makes Arsenal’s search any easier?
Why Creativity, Not a Striker, Should Be Arsenal’s Focus
Carragher doubled down on his argument, insisting that Arsenal’s bigger issue is a lack of chance creation.
“I actually think creating is a big problem [for Arsenal],” he said. “Forget bringing in a No.9—the first thing they might have to do is sign more creative players.”
This is a perspective that not everyone will agree with. Arsenal boast talents like Martin Ødegaard and Bukayo Saka, both of whom are known for their playmaking abilities. However, in key matches, Arsenal have often struggled to break down defensive teams, suggesting that they do need more creative spark in midfield.
What Next for Arsenal?
Despite Carragher’s warning, Arsenal’s links to top strikers remain strong. Benjamin Sesko, a player they pursued last summer before he renewed his Leipzig contract, is still on their radar. Meanwhile, Alexander Isak, who has also caught the attention of Liverpool, remains a name to watch.
But if Arteta follows Carragher’s advice, Arsenal could instead focus on signing a top-tier attacking midfielder or winger—someone who can unlock defenses and provide the service their current forwards need.
So, will Arsenal listen to Carragher’s warning and rethink their transfer priorities? Or will they gamble on finding a world-class No.9 despite the shortage of elite strikers? Either way, this summer’s transfer window could define their chances of finally ending their 20-year title drought. Comment your thoughts below 👇🏽👇🏽
